This comparative photograph, taken by Mark Laita, is actually part of a thirty-four photo series and was created with the intention of expressing the extreme contrasts between individuals in society. This photo was one of the most captivativating to me in the series.
I feel like the senders of the message, the message being contrasts in society, are the subjects. Both of them are sending a strong message through their facial expressions, body language, and clothing. The lady on the left seems to be a an active member of her church. She seems "morally correct" and believes in god. She seems to follow the law, a believer in sin and redemption.
Conversely, The inmate on the right sends an entirely different message. The inmates facial expression, alone, reveals so much about him. His expression seems to be slightly aggresive, very cold and intimidating. He appears to have been through a lot in his life. His clothing and handcuffs let the viewer know he is in prison and the fact he cannot be left alone to be photographed shows the extremity of his criminal punishment.
I feel like this photo mostly exemplifies Pathos because it makes the viewer, or reciever, feel extreme emotions, good and bad. Yet, I feel like this photo also exemplifies Ethos because the subjects are such extremist examples of contrasts in society. For example, the lady on the left is holding a bible to really exemplify the fact she is a good, religious woman and the inmate has hand-cuffs and security guards right next to him to show how extremely criminal he is, even though they could have taken to steps to exclude themselves from the photo. But, by having the guards slightly exposed in the photo visually enhances the message.

Hey, Danica.
ReplyDeleteInteresting thoughts regarding the *sender* of the message. Perhaps the senders were intended to be the subjects, however this artistic choice is a clear message from the artist, himself. What does it mean to say..."I am not the messenger"...."I am not the author of this text, my narrator is"? "I am not the painter of this painting, my subject is"? That's an interesting thought and one worth exploring more. The photo relies upon false dichotomies and seems intent to display a socially constructed contrast.
Need you to explore context (see prompt). Nice work, Danica.