Some of the experts argued that it could be classified as a ‘disorder’ while some of the professionals argued that transgenderism is the result of a semi-traumatic event that caused the child, in their early years, to connect with the parent whose gender they are identifying with. Yet, there are multiple theories that have been suggested describing transgenderism. I feel like most of the experts dismissed the idea of transgenderism as a disorder because they believe that it is purely a social construction. Some of the experts believed that it had nothing to do with the chemistry of one’s brain but had everything to do with society and a child’s development in society and the scenarios or events that mold them.
I support the fact that Tina allowed Brandon to dress up in women’s clothes and act like a girl. Although he was born a boy doesn’t mean he has to live up to his image, in any way. If Brandon found joy and true comfort out of being something he felt he could identify with more that his actual biological structure than he should pursue it. I feel like happiness is a very important thing in life and if the things he did made him happy than why should anyone tell him otherwise. I think that Rosin’s attitude towards her decision was encouraging. The author found a very good way of balancing the text. Rosin was very open-minded and optimistic by backing the different, opposing opinions and facts and making them seem very understood and relevant instead of glorifying the opinion she supports the most and then giving very vague support to the opposition’s points and opinions. At the very end of the story when Rosin claims that they all seemed very happy when they had finally accepted Brandon and allowed him to be himself, as Bridget. I think this shows that the author supports Brandon and his family’s decision by ending the story on such an optimistic, positive note.
Hey, Danica.
ReplyDeleteA thoughtful commentary.
Think critically about the word "disorder." The term "disorder" can bring up all sorts of negative connotations and lead to stigmatization. However, how can medical professional treat a problem pharmacuetically if its not labeled accordingly (i.e. as a disorder)?